Telling Our Story
Home Up Telling Our Story PFI Address Perú-PFI Pork Niche Marketing Director's Letter 2001 $ Statement

 

Telling Our Story

Robert Karp

As moisture returns to the Iowa soils and spring planting begins I find myself reflecting on the past months of intense and often bitter debate over new hog lot legislation in Iowa. Listening to the different sides of the issue has made one thing abundantly clear to me: it is time for PFI and our extraordinary members to tell their story to the rest of Iowa.

On the one hand, there is a growing and increasingly vocal group of citizens who want clean air and water and an attractive countryside. Feeling powerless in the face of large-scale agribusiness, these folks have turned to legislation and the legal process for a remedy.

[Real change requires] the willingness to learn how to effectively communicate with and educate a diverse and ever widening circle of people...

On the other hand, there is a strong segment of the farm population who believe that the citizens described above haven’t got a clue about the realities of farming. As one farmer put it “the environmentalists want to turn Iowa into a park.” This group is struggling to imagine that a happy and prosperous marriage is possible between agriculture and the growing environmental values of society.

Somewhere between these two perspectives stand the bulk of Iowans, who find themselves not quite sure who to believe or what to think. Sensing there is some truth to both perspectives, they have perhaps decided to sit back and watch.

The voices we have heard less of, however, and the voices we need to hear more of on behalf of the future of Iowa agriculture, are those of the environment-minded farmers and the farm-minded consumers—in other words, the bread and butter membership of PFI. Because it’s one thing to find a way to mitigate and control the harmful side effects of an unbalanced approach to farming, and it’s another to farm in a way that is ecologically sound and profitable from the start. This is what is so unique and important about the efforts of PFI members.

Regulations and control in some form have certainly become necessary, but ultimately we need farmers with the desire, capacity and knowledge to farm in harmony with their surroundings. We need consumers who care enough about good farming and good food to change the way they shop. We need businesses and entrepreneurs that allow these farmers and consumers to find each other and make a square deal in the marketplace. And we need policies that encourage all these good efforts.

Helping create this kind of positive future is the day-to-day work of PFI. And yet, as the recent debate suggests, we have a long way to go. How are we going to get there? What are our next steps?

Real Change

Real change, I believe, takes at least two things. On the one hand it takes a nucleus of profoundly committed people who are willing to “live the change” they want to see in the world. PFI members are an inspiring example of just this kind of committed nucleus. A second ingredient, however, is the willingness to learn how to effectively communicate with and educate a diverse and ever widening circle of farmers, consumers, entrepreneurs, policy makers, and community leaders. Here, I think, we have a lot too learn.

A year ago, when I introduced myself to the PFI membership, I expressed my desire to “share with every Iowan the wealth of wisdom, knowledge, passion and vision that live in our members and staff.” Now I am pleased to report that PFI has received two grants focused on helping us develop a three-year “comprehensive communications and community outreach plan” to begin to accomplish that goal.

Over the next three months, with the help of a highly respected consultant here in Iowa, we will begin to craft this plan and over the next three years we will implement it. What might you expect from this process and this plan?

Great Expectations

In the first place, we are going to need your help and insight to develop the plan itself, so you might be called to participate in a focus group or to fill out a survey. We appreciate how busy you are, but your help is vital to the success of this effort.

Secondly, in order to implement this plan we will to need to have more staff time devoted to communications. So you can expect to get to know at least one new PFI staff member designated to this task.

And finally, what might you expect from the plan itself? I don’t know the detailed answers to that yet, but I think you can reasonably expect some of the following:

• some design changes to the PFI logo and website;

• some rethinking of the content, length and design of the PFI newsletter;

• PFI research appearing in new formats designed to suit the needs of different audiences;

• profiles of PFI members, projects and research appearing more regularly in the newspapers and other media;

• more Op Ed pieces in newspapers written by PFI members and staff.

Hopefully we’ll see some new kinds of education and outreach projects too. For example, you might see us putting a larger emphasis on in-depth, how-to workshops and technical assistance designed to put a solid footing under the next wave of farmers interested in sustainable agriculture. You might also see:

• the annual meeting become a 2-day event with scope for an even greater number of participants.

• marketing campaigns designed to educate a larger cross section of consumers about the benefits of buying local and regional foods.

• bus tours or press conferences for policy makers and community leaders that showcase PFI member farms, research and a sustainable approach to agriculture.

• opportunities created for young people to learn, work and research on PFI farms and PFI farmers more active as educators.

• more efforts to build the PFI membership.

Obviously, a good communication and outreach plan isn’t worth much if there isn’t something worth communicating. Without successful members, research, and projects there is no point in making such an effort. So our first priority will always be supporting you, the members, in your efforts to “live the change.”

At the same time, if we cannot multiply the PFI vision a thousand fold across Iowa, there is little likelihood that we will ever move beyond the kind of bitter debates of the past months. Iowans of all stripes, occupations and affiliations have something to learn from the PFI experience.

The soil has been tilled, now is the time to sow our vision across the state.